Michael Fielden

Buyer tools

Rent or own: when does buying pull ahead?

One question, answered honestly: if a Santa Clara County buyer and a renter spend identical amounts every month, and the renter invests every spare dollar, how many years until the owner's net worth passes the renter's? Drag the sliders and watch the answer move.

Owner passes renter in

Monthly payment

Principal and interest, 30-year fixed

All-in cost to own, year one

Payment, taxes, insurance, upkeep, net of tax benefit

Rent, year one

Monthly average across the first year

Gap at year 10

Net worth, owner vs. renter

Owner Renter who invests the difference

Year by year

Year Home value Loan balance Owner net worth Renter net worth Who's ahead